Reviewed by the Nanny Lane team · Last updated
How much does a babysitter cost in Central Islip, NY in 2026?
In Central Islip, NY, the average babysitter earns about $19.69 per hour. For a typical 40-hour week, that works out to roughly $788/week or $3,413/month. Most Central Islip families pay somewhere in the $16–$25/hour range, depending on experience, the number of kids, and what's expected on the job.
Average hourly rate$19.69/hr · Central Islip average
These numbers come from 27 live babysitter listings in Central Islip on Nanny Lane. We update this page whenever the data moves.
- Weekly
(40 hrs) - $788
- Monthly
- $3,413
- Annual
- $40,955
Find babysitters near you
What drives the price
Most Central Islip families pay somewhere in the $16–$25/hour range. Where a given family lands depends on a handful of factors. Three of them drive most of the spread.
01
Experience
Experience is one of the biggest levers on a babysitter's rate.
Nannies with 10+ years, or specialty skills like newborn care or multiple languages, typically command the highest hourly rates.
02
Number of kids
One child is the baseline. Each additional child usually adds $1–$2/hour. Twins and infants tend toward the high end.
+$1 to $2/hour per additional child
| 1 kid (baseline) | $19.69 |
|---|---|
| 2 kids | ~$20.69 |
| 3+ kids | ~$21.69+ |
03
Hours & schedule
Standard weekday daytime hours are easiest to staff. Early mornings, evenings, weekends, and last-minute coverage all push rates up.
10–20%premium for off-hours coverage
| Weekday 9–5 (standard) | — |
|---|---|
| Evening/weekend | +$2–4/hr |
| Last-minute | +$3–5/hr |
Also factor in: live-in vs. live-out · household duties beyond childcare · driving · cooking · travel.
How do Central Islip babysitter rates compare to state and national averages?
Central Islip sits close to the national average for babysitter rates.
Hiring babysitters in Central Islip, NY typically costs about 8% less than the New York average of $21/hour and 5% more than the United States average of $19/hour.
| Area | Average hourly rate | vs. Central Islip, NY |
|---|---|---|
| Central Islip, NY | $20/hr | — |
| New York | $21/hr | +9% |
| United States | $19/hr | -4% |
Where Central Islip, NY fits among nearby cities
10 nearby cities have enough babysitter data to compare, with rates ranging from $18.65/hour in Syracuse to $23.99/hour in New York.
Below: how each compares to the Central Islip, NY average of $19.69/hour.
Nearby cities ranked by babysitter rate
| # | City | $/hr | vs. Central Islip, NY | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | New York | $23.99 | +22% | |
| 2 | Brooklyn | $22.54 | +14% | |
| 3 | Flushing | $22.49 | +14% | |
| 4 | Queens | $21.25 | +8% | |
| 5 | The Bronx | $20.71 | +5% | |
| 6 | Staten Island | $20.28 | +3% | |
| 7 | Albany | $19.41 | -1% | |
| 8 | Rochester | $19.04 | -3% | |
| 9 | Buffalo | $19.03 | -3% | |
| 10 | Syracuse | $18.65 | -5% |
● Most expensive nearby: New York ($23.99)● Least expensive nearby: Syracuse ($18.65)
Tips to find a great babysitter without overpaying
- Be flexible on experience. Some of the best babysitters on the platform have 3–5 years on the job and charge meaningfully less than experienced babysitters with 10+ years. References matter more than years.
- Consider a share. If your kids are similar ages and you live near another family, a share is the single biggest cost reduction available without compromising on care.
- Be specific about hours upfront. Most babysitters will take a slightly lower rate for a guaranteed steady schedule than for a higher-rate, unpredictable one.
- Bundle benefits thoughtfully. Two weeks PTO, a health stipend, transit passes, education assistance, or an annual raise commitment can help close the gap with families offering a higher hourly rate.
- Match rate to responsibilities. A higher rate often makes sense once you add cooking, errands, or driving. Don't compare apples to oranges across listings.
How to reduce nanny costs?
Split the cost of a nanny with another family
and enjoy flexible child care.
and enjoy flexible child care.
How families use Nanny Lane to find a babysitter in Central Islip, NY
Nanny Lane is a marketplace built specifically for connecting families with babysitters — no recruiters in the middle. Most families work through it like this:
- 01
Browse babysitter profiles in Central Islip, NY
Filter by hourly rate, experience, languages, and availability.
- 02
Message the ones who look like a fit
Reach out to the babysitters whose experience and rate match what you're looking for.
- 03
Schedule a phone call, then a paid trial day
Trial days feel awkward at first — that's normal. They're the best way to see how a babysitter fits with your family in real time.
- 04
Hire your babysitter
If you'd rather not handle taxes and payroll yourself, our payroll team can take care of it.
Available babysitters in Central Islip, NY
27 active listings in Central Islip
Nanny Victoria
Nanny Victoria
Central Islip, NY
$20/hr
Full-time
Part-time
Occasional
< 1 year experience
A little bit about me
My name is Victoria. I am 19 years old with a passion for kids. My dream career is to become a pediatric nurse some day. I am taking a semester off from nursing school and am looking for a job in the meantime.
Have experience working with
Special Needs
Certification
CPR
Nanny Inalis
Nanny Inalis
Central Islip, NY
$19/hr
Occasional
6 years experience
A little bit about me
Hi, my name is Inalis, and I’m really excited about the opportunity to babysit for your family. I’m responsible, caring, and love spending time with kids of all ages. I enjoy creating a fun and safe environment — whether that means helping with homework, playing games, or keeping up with their daily routines. Parents can count on me to be dependable, patient, and attentive to their children’s needs.
Have experience working with
Infants
Nanny Caitlin
Nanny Caitlin
Central Islip, NY
$20/hr
Occasional
1 year experience
Have experience working with
Infants
Special Needs
Certifications
CPR
First Aid
Nanny Fany
Nanny Fany
Central Islip, NY
$23/hr
Occasional
5 years experience
A little bit about me
I have an Associate degree in Early Childhood. I work as an Assistant teacher in a UPK classroom.
Have experience working with
Infants
Certifications
CPR
First Aid
Nanny Amy
Nanny Amy
Central Islip, NY
$25/hr
Part-time
Occasional
7 years experience
A little bit about me
Hi! My name is Amy, and I have over seven years of experience caring for children of different ages. Most of my experience comes from helping care for family members and family friends’ children, which has given me a strong understanding of how to create a safe, fun, and nurturing environment for kids.
Have experience working with
Infants
Special Needs
Certifications
CPR
First Aid
Nanny Liah
Nanny Liah
Central Islip, NY
$20/hr
Part-time
1 year experience
A little bit about me
I love kids. I enjoy spending time with the little kids in my family. I have noticed that they like spending time with me too. I always clean up after them and we just have a amazing time every time.
Nanny Suyapa d
Nanny Suyapa d
Central Islip, NY
$20/hr
Part-time
< 1 year experience
A little bit about me
Mi nombre es suyapa amaya madre soltera de 6 niños cuide a todos mis hijos mi hijo mayor tiene 27 mi hija menor 8 tengo experiencia con niños y tengo buena referencia de una familia anterior cuide sus 2 bebés un año y medio puedo recojer los niños de la escuela Lo necesario para los niños soy flexible en los horarios les agradezco una oportunidad hablo español y poco inglés
Have experience working with
Infants
Special Needs
Recent reference
"Suyapa Amaya, who cared for our two daughters since our youngest was just two months old. Suyapa has become family to us—our girls, now three and two, love her deeply. She is caring, reliable, and incredibly nurturing.
She took them on daily walks, kept them engaged, and always prioritized their well-being and happiness. In addition to childcare, Suyapa helped with the children’s laundry and many household tasks, always going above and beyond. She brought peace, warmth, and structure to our home.
Sadly, we relocated to North Carolina, and Suyapa was unable to move with us. We miss her deeply and feel any family would be lucky to have her. I would be happy to speak with you personally to answer any questions or provide further insight. Please don’t hesitate to call me.
Sincerely,
Giuliana Yassa"
- Giuliana Yassa
Nanny Shantese A
Nanny Shantese A
Central Islip, NY
$18/hr
Part-time
< 1 year experience
A little bit about me
I’m 19 years old, I just graduated high school
I used to work at camp r us in 2022.
Then I worked at kids footlocker and champs as a seasonal sales associate.
I’m really great with kids, I’m a hard worker, I’m organized and I am determined to be the best at my job.
I used to work at camp r us in 2022.
Then I worked at kids footlocker and champs as a seasonal sales associate.
I’m really great with kids, I’m a hard worker, I’m organized and I am determined to be the best at my job.
Nanny Maria
Nanny Maria
Central Islip, NY
$18/hr
Full-time
1 year experience
A little bit about me
Tengo experiencia con bebés niños trabaje en daycare... me gustan los niños .... soy atenta y muy amorosa
Have experience working with
Infants
Special Needs