Reviewed by the Nanny Lane team · Last updated
How much does a babysitter cost in Bay Shore, NY in 2026?
In Bay Shore, NY, the average babysitter earns about $18.60 per hour. For a typical 40-hour week, that works out to roughly $744/week or $3,224/month. Most Bay Shore families pay somewhere in the $16–$25/hour range, depending on experience, the number of kids, and what's expected on the job.
These numbers come from 109 live babysitter listings in Bay Shore on Nanny Lane. We update this page whenever the data moves.
- Weekly
(40 hrs) - $744
- Monthly
- $3,224
- Annual
- $38,688
Find babysitters near you
What drives the price
Most Bay Shore families pay somewhere in the $16–$25/hour range. Where a given family lands depends on a handful of factors. Three of them drive most of the spread.
Experience
Number of kids
| 1 kid (baseline) | $18.60 |
|---|---|
| 2 kids | ~$19.60 |
| 3+ kids | ~$20.60+ |
Hours & schedule
| Weekday 9–5 (standard) | — |
|---|---|
| Evening/weekend | +$2–4/hr |
| Last-minute | +$3–5/hr |
Also factor in: live-in vs. live-out · household duties beyond childcare · driving · cooking · travel.
Full-time, part-time, and live-in babysitter rates
| Arrangement | Typical hours | Average rate | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full-time | 35–50 hrs/week | $20.33/hr | |
| Part-time | 10–25 hrs/week | $19.62/hr | |
| Live-in | Set by family | $22.04/hr |
Part-time runs slightly lower per hour than full-time here, which often means strong full-time demand supports higher rates for committed schedules.
Live-in rates here run higher than live-out — uncommon, but typically reflects specialty demand for around-the-clock or live-in newborn care. The trade-off is space — you'll need a private bedroom and ideally a separate bathroom for the babysitter.
How do Bay Shore babysitter rates compare to state and national averages?
Bay Shore runs above the U.S. average for babysitter rates, in line with most major metros.
Hiring babysitters in Bay Shore, NY typically costs about 7% less than the New York average of $20/hour and 11% more than the United States average of $17/hour.
| Area | Average hourly rate | vs. Bay Shore, NY |
|---|---|---|
| Bay Shore, NY | $19/hr | — |
| New York | $20/hr | +7% |
| United States | $17/hr | -10% |
Where Bay Shore, NY fits among nearby cities
10 nearby cities have enough babysitter data to compare, with rates ranging from $17.39/hour in Syracuse to $22.01/hour in New York.
Below: how each compares to the Bay Shore, NY average of $18.60/hour.
Nearby cities ranked by babysitter rate
| # | City | $/hr | vs. Bay Shore, NY | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | New York | $22.01 | +18% | |
| 2 | Brooklyn | $20.21 | +9% | |
| 3 | Yonkers | $20.09 | +8% | |
| 4 | The Bronx | $19.17 | +3% | |
| 5 | Queens | $18.94 | +2% | |
| 6 | Staten Island | $18.45 | -1% | |
| 7 | Buffalo | $17.99 | -3% | |
| 8 | Rochester | $17.73 | -5% | |
| 9 | Bronx | $17.51 | -6% | |
| 10 | Syracuse | $17.39 | -7% |
Tips to find a great babysitter without overpaying
- Be flexible on experience. Some of the best babysitters on the platform have 3–5 years on the job and charge meaningfully less than experienced babysitters with 10+ years. References matter more than years.
- Consider a share. If your kids are similar ages and you live near another family, a share is the single biggest cost reduction available without compromising on care.
- Be specific about hours upfront. Most babysitters will take a slightly lower rate for a guaranteed steady schedule than for a higher-rate, unpredictable one.
- Bundle benefits thoughtfully. Two weeks PTO, a health stipend, transit passes, education assistance, or an annual raise commitment can help close the gap with families offering a higher hourly rate.
- Match rate to responsibilities. A higher rate often makes sense once you add cooking, errands, or driving. Don't compare apples to oranges across listings.
How to reduce nanny costs?
and enjoy flexible child care.
How families use Nanny Lane to find a babysitter in Bay Shore, NY
Nanny Lane is a marketplace built specifically for connecting families with babysitters — no recruiters in the middle. Most families work through it like this:
- 01
Browse babysitter profiles in Bay Shore, NY
Filter by hourly rate, experience, languages, and availability.
- 02
Message the ones who look like a fit
Reach out to the babysitters whose experience and rate match what you're looking for.
- 03
Schedule a phone call, then a paid trial day
Trial days feel awkward at first — that's normal. They're the best way to see how a babysitter fits with your family in real time.
- 04
Hire your babysitter
If you'd rather not handle taxes and payroll yourself, our payroll team can take care of it.
Available babysitters in Bay Shore, NY
109 active listings in Bay Shore
Nanny Aaliyah
Nanny Aaliyah
A little bit about me
Have experience working with
Certification
Nanny Keira
Nanny Keira
A little bit about me
Have experience working with
Nanny Bria
Nanny Bria
A little bit about me
Have experience working with
Certifications
Nanny Nevaeh
Nanny Nevaeh
Have experience working with
Certifications
Nanny Marilyn
Nanny Marilyn
A little bit about me
Have experience working with
