Reviewed by the Nanny Lane team · Last updated
How much does a nanny cost in New Castle, IN in 2026?
In New Castle, IN, the average nanny earns about $12.69 per hour. For a typical 40-hour week, that works out to roughly $508/week or $2,200/month. Most New Castle families pay somewhere in the $8–$20/hour range, depending on experience, the number of kids, and what's expected on the job.
Average hourly rate$12.69/hr · New Castle average
These numbers come from 42 live nanny listings in New Castle on Nanny Lane. We update this page whenever the data moves.
- Weekly
(40 hrs) - $508
- Monthly
- $2,200
- Annual
- $26,395
Find nannies near you
What drives the price
Most New Castle families pay somewhere in the $8–$20/hour range. Where a given family lands depends on a handful of factors. Three of them drive most of the spread.
01
Experience
Experience is one of the biggest levers on a nanny's rate.
Nannies with 10+ years, or specialty skills like newborn care or multiple languages, typically command the highest hourly rates.
02
Number of kids
One child is the baseline. Each additional child usually adds $1–$2/hour. Twins and infants tend toward the high end.
+$1 to $2/hour per additional child
| 1 kid (baseline) | $12.69 |
|---|---|
| 2 kids | ~$13.69 |
| 3+ kids | ~$14.69+ |
03
Hours & schedule
Standard weekday daytime hours are easiest to staff. Early mornings, evenings, weekends, and last-minute coverage all push rates up.
10–20%premium for off-hours coverage
| Weekday 9–5 (standard) | — |
|---|---|
| Evening/weekend | +$2–4/hr |
| Last-minute | +$3–5/hr |
Also factor in: live-in vs. live-out · household duties beyond childcare · driving · cooking · travel.
How do New Castle nanny rates compare to state and national averages?
New Castle runs below the U.S. average for nanny rates — a meaningful budget advantage for families looking here.
Hiring nannies in New Castle, IN typically costs about 10% less than the Indiana average of $14/hour and 24% less than the United States average of $17/hour.
| Area | Average hourly rate | vs. New Castle, IN |
|---|---|---|
| New Castle, IN | $13/hr | — |
| Indiana | $14/hr | +11% |
| United States | $17/hr | +32% |
Where New Castle, IN fits among nearby cities
10 nearby cities have enough nanny data to compare, with rates ranging from $12.12/hour in Terre Haute to $17.26/hour in Carmel.
Below: how each compares to the New Castle, IN average of $12.69/hour.
Nearby cities ranked by nanny rate
| # | City | $/hr | vs. New Castle, IN | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Carmel | $17.26 | +36% | |
| 2 | Fishers | $15.91 | +25% | |
| 3 | Indianapolis | $15.36 | +21% | |
| 4 | South Bend | $14.79 | +17% | |
| 5 | Bloomington | $14.40 | +13% | |
| 6 | Fort Wayne | $14.12 | +11% | |
| 7 | Lafayette | $13.87 | +9% | |
| 8 | Evansville | $13.61 | +7% | |
| 9 | Muncie | $12.37 | -3% | |
| 10 | Terre Haute | $12.12 | -4% |
● Most expensive nearby: Carmel ($17.26)● Least expensive nearby: Terre Haute ($12.12)
Tips to find a great nanny without overpaying
- Be flexible on experience. Some of the best nannies on the platform have 3–5 years on the job and charge meaningfully less than experienced nannies with 10+ years. References matter more than years.
- Consider a share. If your kids are similar ages and you live near another family, a share is the single biggest cost reduction available without compromising on care.
- Be specific about hours upfront. Most nannies will take a slightly lower rate for a guaranteed steady schedule than for a higher-rate, unpredictable one.
- Bundle benefits thoughtfully. Two weeks PTO, a health stipend, transit passes, education assistance, or an annual raise commitment can help close the gap with families offering a higher hourly rate.
- Match rate to responsibilities. A higher rate often makes sense once you add cooking, errands, or driving. Don't compare apples to oranges across listings.
How to reduce nanny costs?
Split the cost of a nanny with another family
and enjoy flexible child care.
and enjoy flexible child care.
How families use Nanny Lane to find a nanny in New Castle, IN
Nanny Lane is a marketplace built specifically for connecting families with nannies — no recruiters in the middle. Most families work through it like this:
- 01
Browse nanny profiles in New Castle, IN
Filter by hourly rate, experience, languages, and availability.
- 02
Message the ones who look like a fit
Reach out to the nannies whose experience and rate match what you're looking for.
- 03
Schedule a phone call, then a paid trial day
Trial days feel awkward at first — that's normal. They're the best way to see how a nanny fits with your family in real time.
- 04
Hire your nanny
If you'd rather not handle taxes and payroll yourself, our payroll team can take care of it.
Available nannies in New Castle, IN
42 active listings in New Castle
Nanny Hannah
Nanny Hannah
New Castle, IN
$12/hr
Part-time
< 1 year experience
A little bit about me
Hello! I’m Hannah and I’m 20 years old! I am going to be entering school for early childhood education, so for 1st-6th graders! I love children and I’ve always loved teaching and helping my classmates or friends with anything they may need! I have been cpr and first aid certified before but I do need to get my recertification. I’ve babysat my sisters child who’s now 3. I am always looking into ways to help children learn and understand them better!
Have experience working with
Special Needs
Nanny Josie
Nanny Josie
New Castle, IN
$12/hr
Part-time
2 years experience
A little bit about me
Hello, I am 21 years old with a 1 year old daughter and a 2 year old son. I have been babysitting for the past year now. I also have experience with babysitting in the past too.
Have experience working with
Infants
Nanny Stevie
Nanny Stevie
New Castle, IN
$12/hr
Part-time
< 1 year experience
A little bit about me
Hello, my name is Stevie, but I got by Eros. I worked as a babysitter for many years of my life, but have doing it since I was 10 years old. I also was a volunteer at Nuview Elementary in California for classes Kinder through Fourth grade. I'm creative, friendly, and hardworking. I love children and have always been described as someone who is "motherly" and "nurturing". Ensuring all children feel safe, happy, healthy, and secure is my top priority.
Have experience working with
Special Needs
Nanny Brianna
Nanny Brianna
New Castle, IN
$12/hr
Full-time
7 years experience
A little bit about me
My name is Brianna I go by bri I have 2 girls aged 4 and 1. I’ve been nannying since I was 12 years old and it’s something I love to do. I’ll keep up with light housework I’m also a very good cook. I’m good with home work.
Have experience working with
Infants
Special Needs
Certifications
CPR
First Aid
Nanny Karissa
Nanny Karissa
New Castle, IN
$14/hr
Full-time
< 1 year experience
A little bit about me
Hi, my name is Karissa Watt. I am 23 years old and I attend Ivy Tech Community College in New Castle Indiana. I graduated from New Castle High School in 2017. I was president of SADD (Students Against Destructive Decisions) and loved to be involved. I attended Anderson University for my first year of college, but sadly found out that I did not enjoy living in Anderson, then shortly returned home. I have a certificate in Business Administration. I have not really had experience other than help taking care of my two nephews that are 5 and 6. I have a one year old daughter who I adore. I am very reliable and trustworthy. I love to be adventurous and fun! I would love to have actual experience of all ages so I can prepare myself for the future! I am CPR certified. Thank you!!
Certification
CPR
Nanny Macy
Nanny Macy
New Castle, IN
$11/hr
Part-time
< 1 year experience
A little bit about me
Hello! I am looking for an opportunity to babysit or be a live-out nanny once I’m done with high school at the end of May/beginning of June 2024. I would love to help out before then working around my school schedule as well. I love working with kids and want to be a teacher someday. I’m getting married in August and wanted something I could do that I love as a job.
Have experience working with
Special Needs
Certifications
CPR
First Aid
Nanny Alexis
Nanny Alexis
New Castle, IN
$11/hr
Part-time
< 1 year experience
A little bit about me
Hi! I’m Alexis I’m a Highschool student, I like to ride bmx, paint, and take photos. I’m really good with children I have many siblings. I really enjoy babysitting
Nanny Diamond
Nanny Diamond
New Castle, IN
$11/hr
Full-time
2 years experience
A little bit about me
Just graduated and would love to have a fun but important job to get me started, as I am soon joining college. I am pretty flexible and have no problem taking care of pets and cleaning up too! I do not have CPR and First Aide certification anymore as it has expired; but I have been trained. Would love to help you and your family :)
Have experience working with
Infants
Nanny Lizzie
Nanny Lizzie
New Castle, IN
$12.23/hr
Part-time
< 1 year experience
A little bit about me
hi i’m lizzie i’m 18 years old i’m about to graduate high school i wanna eventually go to school for cosmetology
Have experience working with
Special Needs