Find a babysitter near you in Shelter Island, NY

Hire directly, with no placement fee.

10 babysitters in Shelter Island

Hire a babysitter in Shelter Island, NY

Cat M. - Seeking Work in Shelter Island

Nanny Cat

Shelter Island, NY
$30/hr
Occasional
3 years experience

A little bit about me

I'm in my early 20s and currently work full-time as the Shelter Children's Advocate at The Retreat in East Hampton. I live on Shelter Island year-round and am open to part-time childcare work outside of my full-time position. I have worked with children of all ages (0-17) and have experience as a kid's art teacher, daycare teacher, camp counselor, and as an academic tutor. I'm very active and enjoy anything and everything outdoors, as well as all things creative when indoors. I'm certified in first-aid, CPR, and ACE's (Adverse Childhood Experiences) as well as various other trainings to do with social work through my position at The Retreat.

Have experience working with

Infants

Certifications

CPR
First Aid
Yas R. - Seeking Work in Shelter Island

Nanny Yas

Shelter Island, NY
$25/hr
Full-time
5 years experience

A little bit about me

I live on the island SI
I am currently available
weekend work.
*weekends
*date nights
I have a reference letter,
I am a careful person , kind, respectful.
I love playing with children, doing crafts, teaching them Spanish, you will love to meet me.

Have experience working with

Infants
Special Needs

Certifications

CPR
First Aid
Marley M. - Seeking Work in Shelter Island

Nanny Marley

Shelter Island, NY
$22/hr
Part-time
< 1 year experience

A little bit about me

Energetic high school graduate seeking babysitting opportunities for the summer before I go to college.

How often do you need a babysitter?

Shannon C. - Seeking Work in Shelter Island

Nanny Shannon

Shelter Island, NY
$30/hr
Part-time
10+ years experience

A little bit about me

Hello there.
I’m a retired teacher of 30 years…I have a masters in early childhood education and a school library degree. I believe that children learn through structured play and love reading, art and cooking with kids. I’m a certified kids yoga teacher too!
I recently moved to Shelter Island after spending 30 summers here and am looking for part-time work.
I love kid and would love to share my expertise with a kind, caring respectful family. I’d be happy to share my resume and look forward to connecting.
Respectfully,
Shannon Coyne

Certifications

CPR
First Aid
Sabina G. - Seeking Work in Shelter Island

Nanny Sabina

Shelter Island, NY
$20/hr
Part-time
3 years experience

A little bit about me

Hi, my name is Sabina, I’m 24 and I’m law student from the Czech Republic! This is my 3rd summer working in the USA. I work mainly in the hotel industry, however I have experience with private housekeeping and gardening in the USA as well.

I love children and playing with them. In my country I used to teach children how to play a piano. In addition, since my mother is a elementary school teacher, I’ve been around children my whole life.

Feel free to contact me with any questions! Sabina

Have experience working with

Special Needs
Paige C. - Seeking Work in Shelter Island

Nanny Paige

Shelter Island, NY
$27/hr
Full-time
6 years experience

A little bit about me

I’m someone who genuinely loves being around people and making a difference, especially in kids’ lives. I’m originally from New Jersey, but I’ve grown up going to Shelter Island and have family there, so it’s always felt like a second home to me. I went to school for four years studying education, and with years of babysitting and hands-on experience in special education, I’m patient, caring, and naturally good at creating a fun, supportive environment where kids feel comfortable and understood. I balance that nurturing side with a strong sense of responsibility and work ethic, whether I’m student teaching, coaching, or helping others adjust to something new. Outside of that, I’m very easygoing and love being active and outdoors I enjoy horseback riding, going on walks or hikes, and spending time at the beach to relax and reset. I think my down-to-earth personality helps people feel comfortable around me pretty quickly.

Have experience working with

Infants
Special Needs

Want to find more babysitters in your area?

Get Started
Dominika K. - Seeking Work in Shelter Island

Nanny Dominika

Shelter Island, NY
$25/hr
Part-time
3 years experience

A little bit about me

Friendly and responsible nanny looking for having fun with kids

Have experience working with

Infants

Certification

First Aid
Mallory P. - Seeking Work in Shelter Island

Nanny Mallory

Shelter Island, NY
$20/hr
Full-time
3 years experience

Have experience working with

Infants
Special Needs

Certifications

CPR
First Aid
S H. - Seeking Work in Shelter Island

Nanny S

Shelter Island, NY
$22/hr
Part-time
4 years experience

A little bit about me

love putting a smile on children's faces experiencing live through them

Certifications

CPR
First Aid

We’re here for you at every step of the process

Finding your nanny

Finding your nanny

Create your profile and connect with nannies that fit your needs.
Hiring your nanny

Hiring your nanny

Run a background check and finalize the details.
Paying your nanny

Paying your nanny

Ease the process of payments and taxes with our payroll service.
Start Your Search
Assortment of photographs arranged loosely on top of one another

Share your nanny with another family

Enjoy attentive care and have playmates for your kids, all at a reasonable cost.
Learn about nanny sharing

Start browsing babysitters near you

Nearby cities to find a babysitter

Image of a piggy bank

What’s the average cost of a babysitter in Shelter Island, NY?

The average cost of a babysitter in Shelter Island, NY is $0 per hour. The cost of a babysitter is dependent on the babysitter’s experience, qualifications and location.
Learn more about babysitter costs

How to Find a Babysitter in Shelter Island, NY

Nanny Lane is a child care website meant to help you find a babysitter in your area. Our child care services include background checks, a dedicated hiring agent, and payroll.

Understand Babysitter Responsibilities in Shelter Island, NY

Before beginning the search for a babysitter, it’s important to understand what you’re looking for and if a babysitter is the right choice for your child care needs. There are lots of benefits to hiring a babysitter such as getting the flexibility of having some more time for yourself or with your partner. When hiring a babysitter, first, you should explore the differences between a nanny and a babysitter. If you’re looking for occasional child care, babysitters are the right choice for you, but if you’re looking for more frequent care, a nanny may be better for your needs.

From there, you can think about what you expect your babysitter to handle so that you can create a profile for nannies to reach out to you. The boundaries for babysitters’ duties can vary from family to family. However, in general, a babysitter is responsible for making sure your kids’ needs are met, including things like ensuring they have opportunities to play and be active. When tasks go beyond child care, for example to housekeeping, laundry, or meal preparation, it’s good practice to communicate these expectations with your babysitter before hiring them. Along with the different duties that you ask for, experience and location in Shelter Island can impact how much you pay your babysitter.

Shelter Island Babysitter Interviews

Once you start connecting with prospective babysitters, the next step is to conduct an interview. To make things a bit easier, here’s a list of some babysitter interview questions to consider asking:

  • Do you have experience being a babysitter?
  • What sort of household tasks are you open and comfortable doing?
  • Do you have any references?
  • Are you trained in First Aid or CPR in New York?
  • Do you have a New York driver’s license? Do you own a car?
  • How do you handle tantrums? Can you share an experience disciplining children?

During the hiring process, it’s essential to ask for references and by asking their references questions you gain a better understanding of they will fit in your family. As you get closer to hiring a nanny, be sure to run a background check to ensure your kids are in good hands. When evaluating a babysitter that you’re considering hiring, make sure you’re setting the foundation for a good relationship with your babysitter. You can do this by being clear about your expectations around babysitter responsibilities and compensation, and of course, by being friendly and welcoming!

And of course, as you learn how to hire a babysitter, Nanny Lane's nanny services are here to help you along the way.

Popular searches in
Shelter Island, NY